Critics who’ve seen Venom are finally allowed to share their social media reactions (screenings began last week) and the consensus isn’t good. The film that is supposed to launch Sony’s Universe of Marvel Characters is drawing unfavorable comparisons to the worst superhero movies of the early 2000s, like Catwoman.

Some critics think Venom is bad, but not that bad. We were even able to locate a positive reaction. The review embargo lifts tomorrow, but it sounds like Sony may need to brace themselves for the impact of a rotten rating.

Venom is in theaters October 5.